How Long Will a Hill Walk Take? Naismith's Rule, Worked Through
A route description says "12 km, 600 m of ascent" and leaves you to work out whether that is a morning or a whole day. The answer most hill walkers reach for is Naismith's rule, a rule of thumb written down by the Scottish climber William Naismith in 1892. It is still the default in guidebooks and route cards because it is simple, and because once you adjust it to your own pace it is surprisingly good. This guide works it through with the Hike Time Calculator, which uses the rule exactly, and shows where it goes wrong.
The rule in one line
Allow one hour for every 5 km of distance, plus one hour for every 600 m of climbing. That is all. The two parts are added together:
- Horizontal part: distance divided by your flat walking pace, 5 km/h by default.
- Climbing part: total ascent divided by your climbing rate, 600 m an hour by default.
The calculator also has a rest allowance, in minutes per hour of walking, which is zero by default. Naismith's figure is moving time. It does not include a single stop.
Worked example: 12 km with 600 m of ascent
Enter 12 km and 600 m and leave everything else at the defaults:
- Flat part: 12 km at 5 km/h is 2.4 hours.
- Climb part: 600 m at 600 m an hour is 1 hour.
- Moving time: 3.4 hours, which the calculator shows as 3h 24m.
Now add a rest allowance of 10 minutes for every hour on the move, which is about right for a sociable day with a few photos, a snack and a map check. The rest adds 34 minutes and the total becomes 3h 58m.
Notice what has happened already. The same walk is three and a half hours on paper and about four hours in real life, and we have not yet changed anyone's pace.
The same rule on four routes
The table runs four common day lengths through the calculator three ways: the bare rule, a gentler pace of 4 km/h with 10 minutes of stops per hour, and that gentler pace with a slower climbing rate of 400 m an hour.
| Route | Naismith (5 km/h, 600 m/h, no stops) | 4 km/h, 600 m/h, 10 min/h stops | 4 km/h, 400 m/h, 10 min/h stops |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 km, 300 m | 2h 6m | 2h 55m | 3h 13m |
| 12 km, 600 m | 3h 24m | 4h 40m | 5h 15m |
| 16 km, 900 m | 4h 42m | 6h 25m | 7h 18m |
| 20 km, 1,200 m | 6h 0m | 8h 10m | 9h 20m |
On the 12 km route, the slowest column is 111 minutes longer than the bare rule. On the 20 km route the gap is more than three hours. The longer the day, the more it matters which column you are in, and the more it costs to guess wrong.
Climb matters as much as distance
Keep the distance at 12 km and change only the ascent. With no climbing at all the rule gives 2h 24m. With 1,200 m of climbing it gives 4h 24m. Two routes that look identical on a map's distance scale can be two hours apart, which is why "how far is it?" is the wrong first question in hill country. Read the ascent off the contours or the route description before anything else, and count every climb, not just the height of the top above the start. A ridge that drops 150 m to a col and climbs back up adds 150 m to your total.
Three adjustments that make it yours
1. Your own flat pace
Five kilometers an hour is a brisk pace on a good path. On rough ground, with a full day pack, or with children, 4 km/h or less is more realistic. At 4 km/h the flat part of the 12 km walk grows from 2.4 hours to 3, and the total without stops becomes 4h 0m.
2. Your own climbing rate
Six hundred meters an hour of ascent is fit-walker territory. Many people climb at 300 to 450 m an hour, especially later in the day or on loose ground. The calculator lets you set it directly. At 400 m an hour the climbing part of our example goes from 1 hour to 1.5 hours.
3. Stops
The rest allowance is the honest part of the plan. Ten minutes per hour is a minimum for most groups. Fifteen to twenty is more like a family day or a photography walk. A long lunch is better added separately, as a fixed block, than spread across the hours.
Calibrate it against a walk you have done
The best way to set the pace boxes is from a walk you remember. Suppose a 10 km route with 450 m of ascent took you about three hours fifty minutes, not counting lunch. The bare rule says 2h 45m, so you are slower than Naismith. Try 3.5 km/h on the flat: 3h 36m. Add a climbing rate of 450 m an hour: 3h 51m. That matches, so those are your numbers for similar ground. Write them down and use them for the next route, rather than the defaults.
Do this once for a summer path and once for a rough, wet or winter day, and you will have two sets of figures that are far more reliable than any table in a guidebook.
Where Naismith's rule is wrong
The rule was written for fit walkers on Scottish hills in good conditions. It is least reliable in these situations:
- Steep or awkward descent. The rule adds nothing for going down. On a gentle path that is fair, but steep, loose or rocky descents are often slower than the flat pace, and they are where tired legs slip.
- Rough ground. Bog, scree, boulder fields, deep heather and snow can halve your pace. No setting in the calculator replaces local knowledge here; slow the flat pace right down and add a margin.
- Altitude. Above about 2,500 m most people climb noticeably slower than at home, and they should, because pushing hard at altitude is a bad idea.
- Heat, wind and load. A hot afternoon or a strong headwind slows everyone, and a heavy pack slows the climb most of all.
- The group. A party moves at the pace of its slowest member, and stops more often than anyone in it would alone.
What the calculator does not cover. It gives moving time plus the rest allowance you enter. It does not know the terrain, the weather, the steepness of the descent, navigation time, or how the group is feeling at hour five. It also does not tell you whether the day fits in the daylight you have. For that, run the same route through the Turnaround Time Calculator, which uses the same Naismith figures and works back from sunset to the latest time you can still be heading up.
Using the answer on the day
A time estimate is useful only if you check yourself against it. Before you set off, note two or three points along the route and the time you expect to reach each one. If you are already twenty minutes behind at the first, you will be later still by the last, because people slow down through a day, not speed up. That is the moment to shorten the route, not the top of the hill.
For a worked example of a shorter, gentler day with a long lunch, see how long a half-day walk with a picnic stop takes. For setting a firm time to turn back, see what time you should turn back on a hill walk.
Before you go. Every time here is an estimate for walkers in good conditions, not a promise. Hill weather can change within the hour: check a mountain forecast, carry waterproof and warm layers, water, food, a map and a charged phone, and tell someone your route and the time you expect to be back. Decide a turnaround time before you start and keep to it. In an emergency call 112, which works across the EU, the UK and India; in the US and Canada call 911. In the UK, ask for the police and then mountain rescue.