What Time Should You Turn Back on a Hill Walk? Setting a Turnaround Time
Most hill-walking accidents that end in a rescue do not begin with a fall. They begin with a decision to keep going a little longer. The summit looks close, the group has come a long way, and nobody wants to be the one to say "we turn back now". A turnaround time takes that decision out of the moment. You set it before you leave, from the daylight and the length of the descent, and when the time comes you turn around, wherever you are. This guide shows how to set one with the Turnaround Time Calculator, and why the same walk gets a very different answer in different months.
What the turnaround time is
It is the latest clock time at which you can still be heading up and still get back to the start with daylight in hand. The calculator works it out in four steps:
- It finds sunset for your latitude and date, then converts it from solar time to the time on your watch, using your longitude and your time zone's offset from UTC.
- It subtracts your margin, the daylight you want left when you reach the car. The default is 45 minutes.
- It subtracts the time it will take you to walk back down, using the same Naismith figures as the Hike Time Calculator: your flat pace for the distance, without the climbing penalty, plus stops.
- What is left is your turnaround time. It also tells you when you would finish if you went to the top and came straight back, and how much daylight would be left.
The example walk
Take a hypothetical hill in the western Highlands of Scotland, at 56.8°N and 5.0°W: 8 km from the car to the summit, with 900 m of ascent, and back the same way. At the calculator's default of 10 minutes of stops for each hour on the move, it takes 3h 37m to go up and 1h 52m to come down, 5h 29m in all.
The same walk in three months
| 17 September | 20 October | 7 November | |
|---|---|---|---|
| UTC offset (summer time or not) | +1 | +1 | 0 |
| Sunset, solar time | 18:09 | 16:49 | 16:08 |
| Sunset, on your watch | 19:23 | 17:53 | 16:12 |
| Turn back by | 16:46 | 15:16 | 13:35 |
The turnaround time moves by more than three hours between mid-September and early November. Part of that is the shortening day. Part of it is the clocks going back at the end of October, which moves sunset an hour earlier on your watch overnight. Both catch people out every autumn.
Does the plan fit?
September, starting at 09:00. You reach the top at about 12:37, finish at 14:29, and have 249 minutes of daylight to spare beyond your 45-minute margin. Plenty of room for a slow lunch or a detour.
October, starting at 10:00. You reach the top at about 13:37, comfortably before the 15:16 turnaround, and finish at 15:29 with 99 minutes in hand. Still a sound plan, but with a lot less room.
November, starting at 10:30. This is where it goes wrong. At the default pace you would reach the summit at about 14:07, but the turnaround time is 13:35. If you carried on to the top anyway, you would finish at 15:59, which is 32 minutes into the margin you meant to keep. The calculator marks the plan as not fitting. The fix is simple: start at 08:30 instead, and the same walk finishes at 13:59 with 88 minutes to spare.
Why the calculator counts stops
Run the late November start again with the stops set to zero, which is the bare Naismith figure. The round trip shrinks to 4h 42m, the finish moves to 15:12, and the calculator says the plan fits, with 15 minutes in hand. It does not fit. No group walks for nearly five hours without stopping. A plan built on a walking time with no breaks in it is optimistic in exactly the direction that ends in the dark, which is why the calculator counts 10 minutes of stops per hour by default.
Slower walkers need an earlier time
Now take the 08:30 November start, which fits at the default pace, and enter a slower party: 4 km/h on the flat and 450 m an hour of climbing. The ascent becomes 4h 40m and the descent 2h 20m. The summit is reached at about 13:10, but the turnaround time has moved to 13:07, because the slower descent needs more daylight. The calculator shows the plan just failing, by 3 minutes.
This is the moment a turnaround time earns its keep. Standing a few minutes below the top at 13:07, the summit is right there. But the margin exists for the twisted ankle, the wrong turn and the companion who is slower than expected, and it is already spent.
Choosing a margin
The default of 45 minutes is a minimum, not a target. Increase it for unfamiliar ground, a steep or rocky descent, a mixed party, short winter days or any doubt about the weather. With a 90-minute margin, the 08:30 November start has a turnaround of 12:50 and still fits, with 43 minutes over. Going the other way, from 45 minutes down to nothing, is never a good idea, because the calculator works to sunset and useful light on a rough descent goes well before it.
What the calculator does not cover. It works to sunset over a flat horizon. In a deep glen or below a ridge, shadow arrives earlier. It knows nothing about weather, cloud, snow, the state of the path, river crossings or the fitness of the slowest person on the day. The walking times are Naismith estimates, with the descent at flat pace. It does not include civil twilight, on purpose: treating twilight as walking time is how a margin disappears.
When the time comes
Turning back short of a summit feels like failure for about ten minutes and like good judgment for the rest of the day. Make it easier on the group by agreeing in advance what happens at the turnaround time: you stop, eat something, take the photograph you would have taken at the top, and head down together. Note where you reached and how long it took; that is exactly the information you need to plan the same hill better next time, with an earlier start or on a longer day. The hill will still be there in spring.
Using it on the hill
- Work out the turnaround time the evening before and tell the whole group.
- Set an alarm on your phone for it.
- Pick checkpoints on the way up and the time you expect to reach each one. If you are behind at the first, you will be further behind later.
- Treat the turnaround time as a hard rule, not a target. Turn earlier if the weather worsens, someone is tiring, or the ground is harder than you expected.
Why the sunset on your watch differs from the sunset in the daylight calculator is explained in why sunset on the hill is not the time on your phone.
Before you go. These are planning estimates. Mountain weather changes fast, and cloud can make the hills dark long before sunset. Carry a head torch with fresh batteries even on a day you expect to finish early, plus warm and waterproof layers, food, water, a map and compass you can use, and a charged phone. Tell someone your route and your expected return time. In an emergency call 112 (EU, UK, India) or 911 (US and Canada); in the UK, ask for the police, then mountain rescue.