How to Budget a Farm-Stay Holiday: Half Board or Self-Catering, Worked Through
A farm stay in the hills is slow travel at its most literal: you live on someone else's working day for a week, eat what the farm produces, and walk out from the yard into the fields and woods. Farm stays go by many names, agriturismo in Italy, farm holidays in Austria and Germany, homestays in many Himalayan villages, and they come in two broad shapes. Some include breakfast and an evening meal in the price. Others are self-catering, with a kitchen and perhaps a box of eggs on arrival. This guide uses the Slow-Travel Trip Budget Calculator to compare the two for a family, and to find the point where one becomes cheaper than the other.
All prices here are illustrative, in a generic currency. They are chosen to show the method, not to describe any real farm or region. Replace each one with real quotes before you decide.
The two options
A family of four, two adults and two children, for six nights, with a 90-per-person journey there and back.
- Half board on the farm: 150 a night for the family, including breakfast and dinner. Daily food on top is only lunch and snacks, 10 per person per day.
- Self-catering cottage: 95 a night. Daily food is everything, 21 per person per day, bought from the farm shop, the village and a weekly market.
Both have the same local transport (6 per person per day) and activities (8 per person per day), because the family will do the same things from either base.
The result
| Half board | Self-catering | |
|---|---|---|
| Lodging, 6 nights | 900 | 570 |
| Daily costs, four people | 576 | 840 |
| Getting there and back | 360 | 360 |
| Total | 1,836 | 1,770 |
| Per person | 459 | 442.50 |
| Per person, per day | 76.50 | 73.75 |
With these figures, self-catering is 66 cheaper over the week. That is a small gap for a lot of cooking and washing up, and many families would happily pay it to have dinner put in front of them after a day outdoors.
The break-even point
The two options differ in only two lines: the room price and the daily food. The half-board room costs 55 a night more, and it saves you two meals a day for four people. So the question is simply what those two meals would cost you to buy and cook yourselves.
Working it through with the same inputs: half board and self-catering cost the same when self-catering food comes to 23.75 per person per day. Below that, self-catering is cheaper; above it, half board wins. In our example the family's self-catering food was 21, a little under the break-even, so self-catering came out ahead.
That break-even figure is the useful thing to take away. Before you book, estimate honestly what your family spends on food per person per day when cooking on holiday, including the treats and the occasional meal out that self-catering families always end up having. If the figure is anywhere near the break-even, the price difference is too small to decide on, and you should choose on everything else.
Estimating your food figure honestly
The easiest way to get the self-catering figure right is to look back rather than forward. Take a recent week at home or on a previous self-catering holiday, add up what the family spent on food, drink and the odd meal out, and divide by the number of people and days. Then adjust for the place: food in remote hill areas can cost more than at home because of the distance it travels, while farm shops and markets can be cheaper for eggs, milk, cheese and vegetables in season. Do not forget drinks. Half-board prices sometimes include water or house wine with dinner and sometimes do not, so ask, and put the cost of anything extra into the half-board food line too.
Children are not adults
The calculator treats every traveler the same, so it counts the two children as two full adults for food. They rarely eat that much. If the children's food costs about half an adult's when self-catering, the average across the family is 15.75 per person per day rather than 21. Enter that instead, and the self-catering total falls to 1,644, now 192 below half board, at 68.50 per person per day.
Half board needs the same care in the other direction. Many farms charge reduced rates for children on half board, so ask for the family price rather than multiplying an adult rate. Enter the room price you are actually quoted, and the comparison stays fair.
What the money does not show
- Time. Self-catering costs an hour or two a day of shopping, cooking and clearing up. On half board, that time is yours, which on a short holiday is worth a lot.
- The food itself. A farm table often serves the farm's own produce, cooked in the local way. That is part of the reason for going, and no shop basket replaces it.
- Fussy eaters and fixed times. Half board means eating what is served when it is served. With young children or particular diets, a kitchen of your own can be the difference between a relaxed week and a tense one.
- Shops. A remote farm may be a long drive from a supermarket, and that drive belongs in the transport line. Check where the nearest shop is, and its hours, before choosing self-catering.
A mixed week
Some farms offer bed and breakfast with an optional dinner, or self-catering with a farm dinner once or twice a week. Costing these is the same method: put the room price you are quoted into lodging, and set the daily food figure to the average of what you will spend across the week. Cooking four nights and eating the farm's dinner on two, for instance, means averaging the cost of those two kinds of day. The calculator will not know the difference, but your averaged figure will carry it.
Farm safety for families
A working farm is a wonderful place for children and a place with real hazards: machinery, animals, slurry pits, water troughs and stacked bales. Ask your hosts on arrival which areas are out of bounds, keep gates as you find them, wash hands after handling animals, and keep a close eye on young children around livestock and vehicles in the yard.
Getting there
Farms in the hills are often at the end of a narrow road, and the last few kilometers can take a surprising time. If you are driving, run the route through the Mountain Drive Time Calculator with a realistic average speed, and aim to arrive in daylight; finding an unfamiliar farm track after dark, with tired children in the back, is a poor start to a week.
What the calculator does not cover. It adds up the figures you enter and divides by travelers and nights. It does not know real farm prices, children's rates, what is included in half board, the cost of drinks, or how much your family actually eats; it treats every traveler alike. The prices in this guide are illustrative. Replace them with real quotes, and with your own honest food figure, before comparing.
Running your own comparison
- Get both prices for your dates, for your family, including children's rates and any cleaning or linen charges.
- Estimate self-catering food per person per day, averaged across adults and children.
- Run both options through the calculator and compare the totals and the cost per person per day.
- If the gap is small, choose on time, food and how your family likes to holiday.
For a straightforward week's budget without the half-board question, see what a week in a mountain village costs.